Shingle vs. Tile Roofing: Exploring Your Roof Replacement Options

June 10, 2024

In Florida, shingles and tiles are two of the most popular roofing materials that you’ll find. While both can protect your home and look great doing it, there are many differences between these shingles and tiles in terms of durability, longevity, and aesthetic options. With all of these many areas to consider, many homeowners aren’t sure how to choose between a shingle vs. tile roof.

Luckily, PITCH Roofing is here to help you make this decision. As seasoned roofing vets in Florida, we understand the ins and outs of both shingle and tile roofing systems. From installation to how your roof will look in 20 years, we’ll walk you through everything you need to know about these two roofing materials.

To start off, let’s cover the basics of what roofing tiles and shingles are.

Shingles vs. Tile Roofs: Material Differences

Shingles vs. Tile Roofs: Material Differences

Living in Florida, shingle roofs are the most common roofing material that you’ll see. These roofing systems are usually made of asphalt shingles, which are a protective base board that is coated in asphalt and protective granules to protect your shingles against impact damage, wind, and heavy rains.

Alternatively, shingle roofing can also include composite shingles. Also known as synthetic shingles, these are made of rubber and other recycled materials to imitate the look of wood shake or slate roofing. This makes them popular among homeowners who want the aesthetic of luxury roofing materials without the high roofing costs!

There’s variety among roofing tiles, too. Tiles generally have a more elegant profile than shingles, but they come in two varieties: clay and concrete. Each of these materials performs slightly differently, but the end result is a long-lasting roofing system that protects your roof while also delivering on that classic Florida style.

Now that we’ve got the basics out of the way, let’s look at how to decide between a shingle vs. tile roof replacement!

Choosing a Shingle vs. Tile Roof in Florida

Choosing a Shingle vs. Tile Roof in Florida

As Floridians, our roofs need to be ready for just about anything. To make sure your home is prepared for the next major storm, let’s talk about all of the differences between roofing shingles and tiles!

Longevity of Shingle and Tile Roofs

One of the biggest differences in shingle vs. tile roofs is in lifespan. For your average asphalt shingle roof in Florida, you can expect 20-25 years of life when you use reliable contractors and high-quality architectural shingles. This number jumps up considerably for composite shingles, which can last between 40 and 50 years.

The numbers are noticeably different for tile roofs, though. A concrete tile roof will average around 50 years, whereas a clay tile roof could last for a century or more. So while both shingles and tiles have a wide range in how long they can last, tiles are, generally speaking, your best bet for a roof that will last.

Roof Installation Costs

Calculating roofing costs is always tricky. That’s because your total installation costs will depend largely on your roof’s unique features and size. However, we can still cover the differences in the average costs of shingle vs. tile roofs.

The cost breakdown of shingle and tile roofing materials in Florida is:

  • Asphalt Roofing Shingles: Architectural shingles cost between four and eight dollars per square foot. This is partially what makes them so popular; they’re a great blend of durability and low roofing costs.
  • Composite Roofing Shingles: These long-lasting shingles cost between seven and 14 dollars per square foot in Florida. This is a significant price jump, but still cheaper than real shake or slate roofing!
  • Concrete Roofing Tiles: Including installation costs, concrete tile roofs cost between seven and 19 dollars per square foot. While more expensive than shingle roofing, this is still considered a more affordable tile roofing system.
  • Clay Roofing Tiles: This luxury roofing material costs between $12 and $21 per square foot, making it the most expensive option on this list. But with its classic Florida profile and unbeatable longevity, it’s not hard to see why!

Roofing costs vary depending on many factors, and there are always ways to get an affordable roof replacement. But these ranges should help you pick out which roofing material best suits your roofing budget.

Hurricane Resistance

While humidity and UV exposure do a number on local roofs all year round, hurricanes will destroy your roof all at once. So when choosing between a shingle vs. tile roof, it helps to know how your new roofing system stands up to major storms.

Generally, shingles are a little worse than tiles when it comes to standing up against hurricanes. For example, asphalt shingle roofs usually only get wind resistance up to 110 mph or so. This is a great figure that will protect against tropical storms and many hurricanes, but it simply can’t match the 150 mph wind resistance of clay tile roofs.

In short, you’re a lot more likely to find stray shingles in your yard after a storm than to find uplifted tiles. Thankfully though, both shingle and tile roofs can stand up to the heavy downpours that come with major storms!

Roof Maintenance Schedule

Both shingles and tiles can give you a roof that will last for decades. But how many repairs will your roof need over those decades? This is an important consideration for the cost of your roof across its lifetime.

Shingles will typically need more maintenance than tile roofs. This doesn’t mean that shingle roofs bring a lot of headaches, but rather that from time to time your shingles might get torn off by high winds or baked in the hot Florida sun. When this happens, it’s usually quick and easy to get a handyman to your home to perform these minor repairs.

Clay tiles are less likely to need much maintenance other than occasional washing to clear off algae. The one exception to this, though, comes from impact damage. Most tile roofs are fairly brittle, so when hail or storm debris strikes a tile, it can shatter it. This is more expensive than replacing broken or missing shingles, but the overall roof repair costs are still low, and simple repairs like these shouldn’t take much time for experienced roofers to resolve.

For both shingle and tile roofs, it’s a good idea to get regular roof inspections to ensure that your roof stays in top form throughout its life!

Get a Free Shingle or Tile Roofing Estimate

Above are some of the biggest considerations to make when deciding between a shingle vs. tile roof replacement. And whether you have lingering questions or you feel ready to make a final decision, the next step is collecting your free roofing estimate.

When you get your estimate, you’ll be able to talk with a roofing professional and get personalized answers to all of your questions. To get started, you can schedule your roof inspection by calling us at 727-607-4280 or scheduling your free estimate online.

And if you already know what you want, then we can help you speed through the roofing process. Get an online-only estimate and we’ll use satellite images to measure your roof and prepare a customized estimate using your chosen roofing material!

At the end of the day, deciding between a shingle vs. tile roof largely comes down to personal needs and preferences. Whatever roofing material you decide on is the right one. As experienced roofers, our job is just to help you make your decision and make sure that you get a great, long-lasting roof put on your home. If you want to see what real, local roofing professionals can do, reach out to Pitch and let us prove our value and earn your business!

Last Updated:June 10, 2024