How to Decide Whether to Repair or Replace Your Roof

June 14, 2024

Problems with your roof are never fun to deal with, but there’s a world of difference between getting roof repairs and a roof replacement. Hammering on a few missing shingles can easily cost under $500, whereas a roof replacement will cost thousands. So when your roof starts leaking, deciding whether to repair or replace your roof is one of the first questions you need to answer.

PITCH Roofing is here to help you make the best decision for your roof. As a homeowner, it can be tough to tell what’s causing your roofing issues. After all, a leak can be a minor inconvenience or a sign of major water damage. But there are ways you can tell whether you should repair or replace your roof in Florida.

Should You Repair or Replace Your Roof?

Should You Repair or Replace Your Roof

One of the biggest factors in repairing or replacing your roof is the extent of the damage. For example, missing a handful of shingles after a storm is almost never a reason to replace a roof. On the other hand, you may still have the option of getting a repair even if your roof has been severely damaged.

In most situations, you get to choose whether or not you should repair or replace your roof. You may have major damage that should be replaced, but most experienced contractors will be able to come up with a repair solution that can give your roof more time. So how do you know whether to bite the bullet and get a roof replacement or get a temporary fix? Well, that will come down to the specifics of your roof and your situation.

How the Age of Your Roof Affects the Decision to Repair or Replace

At a certain point, a roof gets so old that your only option is to replace it. But there is no definite line where you have to replace it. Instead, it’s about balancing the age of your roof with how well it’s protecting your home.

What kind of issues indicate that you should replace an old roof? There are many, but some of the most common signs it’s time to replace a roof include:

  • Recurring roof leaks
  • Interior water damage on your ceiling
  • Having missing or damaged shingles across more than 25% of your roof
  • Algae and mold developing on your roof

If your roof is getting on in years and shows these issues, replacing it is probably the right decision. You may be able to repair it and buy yourself more time, but another issue will come up, and repairing the same issues indefinitely will only cost you more in the long run.

Considering the Cost of Roof Repairs

One good way to decide whether to repair or replace your roof is to look at how much you’d have to spend on fixing your roof. For example, if your roof is about to get its third $2,000+ repair in the past handful of years, then this could be a sign that it’d be cheaper to just replace the roof and stop issues from recurring.

Roofing costs always vary, but in Florida, you can expect an architectural shingle roof to cost between $14,000 and $20,000. This is undeniably a major expense. But it’s still cheaper than the cost to keep replacing the same issues over and over again. For this reason, you may consider replacing a problematic roof even if it’s fairly young.

Unfortunately, even newer roofs can need replacing if they’ve been improperly installed. Issues with ventilation, underlayments, and properly distributed weight can all cause newer roofs to need replacing. While nobody wants to replace a roof that’s under 20 years old, it’s important to consider how much you’re spending on repairs. It’s also important to carefully choose your roofers to ensure that your new roof doesn’t run into these same issues.

Budgeting for Roof Repairs vs. Replacement

Budgeting for Roof Repairs vs. Replacement

Roofing problems don’t come on a schedule. And if you don’t have the money available for a roof replacement, you may be tempted to go with the cheaper solution and get a repair as a band-aid. This can work as a temporary measure to give you more time to save, but if your roof needs replacing, then there’s no repair that can change that.

Putting money into repairs to buy time can add up quickly. This leads to a frustrating cycle where you’re trying to save up for a roof replacement but your money keeps going to repairs. Luckily, there is a way out of this vicious cycle: roof financing.

At Pitch, we proudly offer 0% interest roof financing to avoid exactly this problem. Whether you repair or replace your roof should come down to the right decision for your home, not just your budget. By getting the money up-front, you can get the secure roof you need now and pay it off on a more comfortable schedule. Additionally, this will likely be cheaper than having pay for repairs every few months as you try to save up!

Start the Roof Repair or Replacement Process

At the end of the day, only you can decide whether to repair or replace your roof. But our veteran roofing experts can give you the information you need to make an informed decision. That all starts with collecting your free, no-obligation roofing estimate.

To get a detailed, comprehensive estimate outlining all your roofing options, call us at 727-607-4280 or schedule your estimate online. After a brief roof inspection, you’ll get a chance to ask any and all questions about your roofing options, and we’ll prepare a roofing estimate that’s suited to your roof and what you’re looking for. From there, the only thing left to do will be to pick your roofers!

At Pitch, we believe in the quality of our work. That’s why we’re not asking for anything special — just the opportunity to show you what our experienced roofers can do. If you’re on the fence about whether to repair or replace your roof, let our experts help you make the right decision for your budget and your home.

Deciding to Repair or Replace Your Roof FAQs

Q: When should I replace my roof?

A: Normally, you’ll replace your roof when it reaches the end of its life cycle. For shingle roofs, this is after 20-25 years. However, you may need to replace it earlier if your roof fails due to poor installation or because of hurricane damage.

Q: Can I just replace shingles instead of replacing the whole roof?

A: Yes, if your roof has lost a few shingles to a passing storm, you should be able to replace a handful of missing shingles without replacing the entire roof. There is one caveat, though. If your roof is missing large sections of shingles or has sustained structural water damage, you may need to replace your entire roofing system.

Q: How often should I get a roof inspection?

A: For roofs installed more than five years ago, get a roof inspection once every two years and after major storms. This will let you stay ahead of any damage and repair it as it comes.

Q: Should I replace my roof if I plan to move?

A: If you plan to sell your home in the next few years, you may be able to get repairs so that you’re not on the hook for a roof replacement. However, if your roof needs many repairs, it may be harder to sell, whereas selling a home with a new roof can give you a lot more bargaining power.

Q: Is it cheaper to repair or replace a roof?

A: In many situations, roof repairs are cheaper than roof replacements. But if you look at the lifetime of your roof, it may be cheaper to replace a damaged roof now. This is because continuing to pay for repairs indefinitely quickly adds up.

Last Updated:June 28, 2024