Pros and Cons of a Spanish Tile Roof in Florida

Spanish Tile Roof
June 5, 2024

If you’ve been considering getting a tile roof replacement, someone has probably recommended getting a Spanish tile roof. But while Spanish clay tiles have a long history in Florida, they’re not right for everyone. So how do you know if they’re the right choice for your roof replacement?

Well, this article is a great place to start. We’re PITCH Roofing, your team of local tile roofing professionals. Keep reading for our breakdown of Spanish tile roofs and the value they can bring to your Florida home. But to get started, let’s define exactly what Spanish roofing tiles are and how they’re made.

Spanish Tile Roof Manufacturing

Spanish Tile Roof Manufacturing


Spanish roofing tiles are a type of barrel tile or S-shaped tile. These names come from their shape, which looks like half a barrel when installed but is actually S-shaped to allow for the tiles to lock together beneath your roof. Since the mechanism of adhesion happens below your roof, this vulnerable area is protected and will experience little wear and tear over the years.

This has always been the general shape of Spanish roofing tiles, but their composition has changed a lot over the centuries. These tiles were originally created using nothing but clay, water, and a kiln. While this produced strong, resistant tiles, modern roofing technology has made a lot of improvements.

For one thing, Spanish tiles are now made using machines that can create the perfect tile shape every time. This means drastically lower manufacturing costs, making a Spanish tile roof much more affordable for homeowners. Additionally, modern Spanish tiles have added protective coatings to better resist things like rain and UV rays.

In short, Spanish tiles used to be good in Florida, but now they’re great. But are they right for your home? The only way to know is to consider both the good and the bad of a new Spanish tile roof.

Pros and Cons of a Spanish Tile Roof in Florida

Pros and Cons of a Spanish Tile Roof in Florida

Spanish tile roofs have been popular in Florida for centuries. And with modern roofing improvements, that popularity has only gone up. But no roofing material is right for every home, so let’s talk about everything you need to know before scheduling your tile roof replacement.

Pro: Long Lifespans and Low Maintenance

If you want a roof that you can trust to last a long time without many issues, a Spanish tile roof is an excellent option. For one thing, clay roofing tiles last longer than any other roofing material, with lifespans ranging from 70-100+ years!

And during this long lifespan, it’s unlikely that your roof will have many problems. A Spanish tile roof can withstand high winds, heavy rains, and extreme UV exposure. So even with Florida’s unpredictable weather, you can still count on your tile roof to stay put!

Con: High Costs of a Spanish Tile Roof in Florida

Remember how we said that Spanish tile roofs have become more affordable thanks to modern roofing technology? That’s true, but “more affordable” is relative. Even today, Spanish roofing tiles are a luxury roofing material with a complex installation, so you can count on these roofs costing more than the average roof in Florida.

So how much does a Spanish tile roof cost in Florida in 2024? The latest numbers put the average cost between $15 and $22 per square foot for these clay tiles. Keep in mind that total tile roof replacement costs depend on the size of your roof, its unique hills and valleys, and its accessibility. But for most homeowners, it’s fair to say that a Spanish tile roof is a major property investment!

Pro: Local Charm and Aesthetics

Spanish tile roofs just make sense in Florida. This is especially true if you have a Spanish- or Mediterranean-style home. By adding a Spanish tile roof, you can give your home a look that’s tropical, modern, and distinctly Florida.

And on the Florida housing market, this kind of charm has a lot of value. Thanks to increased curb appeal and its many protective features, a Spanish tile roof will substantially increase the value of your home. This makes clay tile roof replacements a popular option for people who plan to stay in their homes forever as well as people who plan to sell one day.

Con: Brittle Roofing Tiles

In a lot of ways, clay tiles are hardy and resilient. But the way they handle impact damage could be an exception. While these tiles are resistant to the worst that Florida’s weather can throw at them, their brittleness means that shattering is an issue that homeowners commonly run into.

Now, it’s important to note that you won’t be dealing with shattered tiles every other month if you get a Spanish tile roof. But from time to time, storm debris or hail could crack a tile on your roof. The silver lining, though, is that replacing cracked tiles is a quick and easy repair, so it shouldn’t eat up much of your time or budget.

Pro: Eco-friendly Roofing

Whether you’re a committed environmentalist or you just want a lower monthly energy bill, Spanish roofing tiles can do a lot for you. For one thing, clay is an entirely natural material that’s easy to recycle. This gives tile roofing a big leg up on asphalt shingle roofs, which end up depositing about 107 billion shingles into landfills every year.

Additionally, Spanish clay tiles create excellent insulation on your roof. In the hot summer months, this means your roof will keep the cool air in and the hot air out. When you combine this with their UV-resistant coatings, Spanish tile roofs are able to reliably keep your home cool to help both the environment and your monthly budget.

Get a Spanish Tile Roofing Estimate

As you can see, there are both upsides and downsides to getting a Spanish tile roof replacement. Ultimately, the only person who can decide what’s right for your roof is you. We’re just here to make sure that you get the excellent roofing services that you deserve.

When you’re ready to take the first step in getting a new roof, reach out to the pros at Pitch. For a free, no-obligation estimate, you can call us at 727-607-4531 or schedule your free estimate online. Whether a Spanish tile roof is right for you or not, we’ll be happy to walk you through your options and answer any questions that you have!

We know that there are plenty of roofers to choose from in Florida. But give Pitch a chance, and we’ll show you why we’re Florida’s trusted tile roofing partners!