How to Choose a Metal Roof vs. Shingles

Metal Roof vs. Shingles Cost in Florida
April 26, 2024

If you’re due for a new roof, you’re probably tempted to upgrade to a metal roof. A lot of Floridians are — metal roofs are more durable, better able to handle storms, and they last longer than shingles. Despite these benefits, though, many Floridians are still on the fence when it comes to choosing a metal roof vs. shingles.

We’re here to help you make a decision. And when you need expert advice on roofing in Florida, there are no better experts than those at PITCH Roofing. Let’s talk about the deciding factors between metal and shingle roofs to help you get ready for your upcoming roof replacement!

The Value of a Metal Roof vs. Shingles

The Value of a Metal Roof vs. Shingles

You might already know that metal roofs are more expensive than shingle roofs. But just how much more expensive, exactly? To tell which roof is better for your home, it’s important to know the value of each roofing material.

Of course, there’s a wide price range for both metal and shingle roofs. For example, a copper roof will cost substantially more than a roof made with Galvalume. But if we’re looking at average metal roofing costs, those tend to fall between $10 and $18 per square foot.

Shingles come at a much more budget-friendly price. Shingle roofing costs are generally low, even for high-quality architectural shingles. In fact, these shingles generally cost between five and eight dollars per square foot.

Comparing these numbers, we can see that a 2,000-square-foot metal roof replacement would cost between $20,000 to $36,000. That same roof would cost between $10,000 and $16,000 to replace with asphalt shingles.

As you can see, a shingle roof replacement costs roughly half as much as a metal roof replacement. But the price tag shouldn’t be the only way that you determine the value of your roof. To fully understand the value of a metal roof vs. shingles, you’ll have to consider what kind of product your money buys you.

Long-term Roofing Maintenance Costs

Nobody could deny that metal roofs cost more up-front than shingle roofs. You don’t just pay for your roof once, though. You pay for it across its lifespan, so you should consider what kind of bills your new roof could wrack up over the years.

And if you want a roof that won’t need a lot of repairs, then a metal roof might be worth that higher price point. While metal roofs are rated for winds of 140+ mph, high-quality shingle roofs are usually rated for around 110 mph winds. When a storm comes through and blows shingles off one roof, the metal roof next door will be completely undamaged and won’t require any repairs.

Across the lifespan of your roof, this represents savings of thousands of dollars. And it’s doubled when you consider all of the things that metal roofs can protect your home against better than shingles, including:

  • Fire: Metal roofs are non-combustible.
  • Hail: Metal roofs are highly resistant to denting, while hail can cause roofing shingles to bend or break off.
  • Leaks: Metal roofs have fewer seams and joints than shingle roofs, reducing the risk of leaks and water infiltration over time.
  • Pests: Since metal roofs don’t have as many entry points as shingles, they’re much more resistant to common pests like bugs and mice.
  • Mold: Year-round humidity is a serious problem for Florida roofs, but since metal roofs don’t absorb moisture like shingle roofs, they’re better able to resist mold and mildew.

You should consider all of these factors when determining what kind of roof you can afford. After all, saving a bit of money now doesn’t help when you’ll just spend that money on repairs in the future.

Think of Future Metal Roof vs. Shingle Roof Replacements

Think of Future Metal Roof vs. Shingle Roof Replacements

Finally, when deciding between a metal roof vs. shingles, you should try to think about your future roof replacements. After all, whatever roof you decide to get probably won’t be the last one that your home ever sees. So it only makes sense to compare the costs of roof replacements over time to make a truly equal comparison. And when we do that, metal roofing starts to look a lot more appealing.

Let’s start by looking at how long these roof replacements will last. An asphalt shingle roof will, under the best circumstances, last about 25 years with proper installation and maintenance. This isn’t bad, but it doesn’t hold a candle to the 50-70 years you can expect a metal roof to last in Florida.

When we look at it this way, you can see that one metal roof replacement lasts as long as two shingle roof replacements. This means we should mentally double the cost of a shingle roof replacement in order to compare it to the value of a metal roofing system. When we do this, it’s clear that a metal roof costs about as much as a shingle roof in the long run. And with a metal roof, you at least get enhanced security and minimal repairs over the years.

Get a Free Estimate for a Metal or Shingle Roof Replacement

For all of the reasons above, you should seriously consider getting a metal roof replacement instead of shingles. However, the simple truth is that many people cannot afford the high up-front costs of a metal roof. So whether you decide on a metal or shingle roof replacement, we can help.

No matter what kind of roof replacement you choose, it all starts with an estimate. Call us at 727-607-4553 or schedule your free estimate online! Or, if you don’t need a meeting to discuss your roofing options or an in-person roof inspection, you can even get a free, online-only estimate. Because at Pitch, we’re not just trying to sell, we’re trying to make your life easier.

Choosing between a metal vs. shingle roof replacement is a big decision. And we don’t have a preference for which one you pick — we just want you to get the roof that makes sense for you and your family. Give Pitch a chance to show you that we’re the real deal and see what our local roofing experts can do for you and your property!

Last Updated:May 31, 2024